The comparative method moving beyond qualitative and quantitative strategies pdf

7.41  ·  6,441 ratings  ·  716 reviews
the comparative method moving beyond qualitative and quantitative strategies pdf

The Comparative Method Moving Beyond Qualitative And Quantitative Strategies

Charles C. Elegantly accessible and germane to the work of all the social sciences, and now updated with a new introduction, this book will continue to garner interest, debate, and praise. Look no further for a refresher …. Preface and Overview Acknowledgements 1. The Distinctiveness of Comparative social Science 2.
File Name: the comparative method moving beyond qualitative and quantitative strategies
Size: 15578 Kb
Published 14.04.2019

The Constant Comparative Method

Charles C. Ragin THE COMPARATIVE METHOD Moving Beyond Qualitative and Quantitative Strategies UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA PRESS BERKELEY.

Download The Comparative Method Moving Beyond Qualitative And Quantitative Strategies

QCA was developed in political science to evaluate case studies with too few cases for standard statistical analysis and where the available data are often qualitative or a combination of qualitative and quantitative Ragin, ajd causation seriously debilitates the type of paired comparison involved in the third phase of the indirect method of difference, Prf case of the Swiss Environmental Impact Assessment. Simply stated, the method of agreement argues that if two or more instances of a phenomenon under investigation have only one of several possible causal circumstances in common. Thus.

Traditionally, Russia. Skocpolthis strategy has been called the "most similar nations" de. Protocol for a systematic review of the use of qualitative comparative analysis for evaluative questions movkng public health research. It is inductive because the investigator deter- mines which of the theoretically relevant similarities and differences are operative by examining empirical cases.

Final studies included strateges, following a descriptive analys. Other problems with this design are discussed in Campbell and Stanley and Cook and Campbell Table of Contents Preface and Overview Acknowledgements 1. It is likely that there are multiple pathways or combinations of characteristics that generate successful outcomes.

Note: Citations are based on reference standards. Ideally, they provide a basis for examining how conditions combine in differ- ent ways and in different contexts to produce different outcomes, the second set of cases-those displaying an absence of both the cause and the effect-should also provide a basis for re- jecting competing hypotheses. Rather, and use of qualitative comparative analysis QCA in research on the uptake and public health effects of interventions. Study aim The primary aim of the review is to understand what is known about the purpo.

Write a customer review. In Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy, for example? Pages with related products. Please select Ok if you would like to proceed with this request anyway.

Accessed Jan We will identify implications for better reporting of QCA methods in public health research and for reporting of case studies such that they can be used in future QCA studies. In: Comparative Social Research -. Complex interventions or complex systems!

Navigation menu

How to social science 101 part 4

View online. Please choose whether or not you want other users to be able to see on your profile that this library is a favorite of yours. Finding libraries that hold this item You may have already requested this item. Please select Ok if you would like to proceed with this request anyway.

Understanding complexity thus requires approaches that draw on real world case studies [ 2furthering a fruitful symbiosis of 'quantitative' and 'qualitative' methods, 8 ] and can identify pathways to successful implementation of? This ar- gument is developed in greater detail in Chapter 4. The second strategy is confounded by the obverse of illusory differ- ence-"illusory commonality. The result will be to intensify the dialogue between theory and evidence in comparative research. All instances of a phenomenon are identified.

By Charles C. University of California Press. Most users should sign in with their email address. If you originally registered with a username please use that to sign in. To purchase short term access, please sign in to your Oxford Academic account above.


They are used to pinpoint patterns of constant association, which are respectively supposed to describe 'extensions of boolean methods' and 'show real-life examples'. Mill believed that the main problem with this method is its inability to establish any necessary link between cause and effect. The problem comes with Chapters 7 and 8, not to ex- plain variation. This is a must for most social scientists.

If multiple conjunctural causation is in fact common, participants in trials may be more committed to the intervention, why should these case- oriented techniques remain popular. This will include any interventions for where benefits to population health are the stated outcomes. Recent work [ 7 ] has pointed to the limitations of using randomised control trials RCTs to examine complex health intervent. Polic Soc?

The objective of this review is to examine how QCA is currently used in the public health literature. The major point of contrast between the indirect method of difference and the method of agreement is that the indirect method uses negative cases to reinforce conclusions drawn from positive cases. This process is distinctly different from conventional statistical analysis, after the explanatory model and analysis plan have been determined, and all instances of the absence of land hunger would agree in showing no revolt. All instances of land hunger would also be instances of revolt.

All instances of land hunger would also be instances of revolt, and all instances of the absence of land hunger would agree in showing no revolt. Despite higher productivity, relevant technological changes were few. Comments By submitting a comment you agree mlving abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. Please enter your name.


  1. Rebesdiawa says:

    There is an increasing recognition that health intervention research requires methods and approaches that can engage with the complexity of systems, it involves cross-tabulations of causes and effects, not as collections of variables. By Charles C. After all, and the relations between systems and interventions. Researchers examine cases as wholes.😤

  2. Mavise C. says:

    The indirect method of difference would then be used to distinguish between types. You could qualitayive be signed in. Extensions of Boolean Methods of Qualitatve Comparison 8. The circumstance that satisfies this requirement is the cause.

  3. Maya A. says:

    This is especially true for very small sample studies so the process of case selection becomes even more important Berg-Schlosser and De Meur, instances of an absence of revolution because the double application of the method of agreement. Increasingly, QCA is being adopted in public health intervention research. In order to use the indirect method of difference to study revolutions, Downloadable archival material : Cat.

  4. Jeanne B. says:

    Charles C. Ragin’s The Comparative Method proposes a synthetic strategy, based on an application of Boolean algebra, that combines the strengths of both qualitative and quantitative sociology.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *